Frequently asked questions
What is a pie mini? Do you have full size 9 in pies?
Our signature 5-inch, chef-crafted pie is cut into six palm-sized slices, each packing all the flavor of a classic pie into a few perfect bites. A pie mini is perfect for 1–3 people, depending on your appetite, while our traditional 9-inch pies serve 6–8. Craving something bigger? We offer full size 9-inch pies for the holidays! Follow us on Instagram @fillings.nyc to be the first to know when preorders go live.
What is a pie flight?
Can't pick just one? Neither can we. Our 3 slice flight lets you mix and match any three flavors, while our 9 slice flight includes all five Fillings classics plus four additional slices of your choice. A little of this, a little of that, a little of everything.
Can I walk in, or do I need to preorder?
Come on in! You can visit our West Village pop up at 272 Bleecker Street to grab your Fillings, no preorder necessary! You can also find a selection of our pies at Meadow Lane. For special orders, larger quantities, and holiday pies, we recommend ordering in advance to make sure you get exactly what you're craving.
How should I store my pies, and how long do they last?
Our pies are best enjoyed fresh, but a little planning never hurt anybody! Refrigerated: Keep your pies refrigerated and enjoy within 3 days of purchase. Frozen: If purchased frozen from Meadow Lane or our West Village pop up, your pies can be stored in the freezer for up to 3 months. Just make sure they're tightly sealed in their original box and placed inside a Ziploc bag to maintain freshness. Ready to dig in? Every pie has its sweet spot! Check out our Pie Gallery to see how each flavor is best enjoyed, whether frozen, chilled, or at room temperature.
Where can I find the menu for weekly rotating flavors?
All weekly rotating flavors will be posted on Mondays on our Instagram: @fillings.nyc
Can we order custom pie minis?
Yes! We offer a wide range of flavors and can create custom menus for catering, events, and special occasions. For more information or to place a custom order, please email us at hello@fillingsnyc.com.
Are you a nut free bakery?
Some of our pies are made without nuts; however, all Fillings pies are prepared in a shared kitchen that also handles peanuts and tree nuts. We take precautions to prevent cross contact, but the pies are not made in an allergen-free environment.
Do you serve gluten free or vegan pies?
Select drops will be gluten-free or vegan. Please be sure to check our Instagram @fillings.nyc to see what we currently have available. We also offer gluten-free custom orders for events and special occasions!
Where can I find allergen information about your pies?
You can find ingredients and allergen information for each of our signature flavors in our Pie Gallery. For new pies, weekly specials, and limited-edition flavors, allergen information will be available in store or on our Instagram @fillings.nyc. All Fillings pies are prepared in a shared kitchen that handles common allergens, including peanuts, tree nuts, wheat, dairy, and eggs. While we take precautions to minimize cross contact, we cannot guarantee an allergen-free environment. Have a specific question? Email us at hello@fillingsnyc.com and we'll be happy to help!